Water Street Cafe in Stonington Borough closed after dinner service on November 7, ending a 32 year run in southeastern Connecticut. The restaurant at 143 Water St. was opened by Stephanie Hayes-Houlihan and Walter Houlihan on April 14, 1994, according to reports by the Connecticut Post, Patch, and NewsBreak’s source material.
The owners announced the closing publicly and thanked customers for the memories, camaraderie, and support they shared over the years. Reports cited by the Connecticut Post and Patch said the announcement did not give a specific reason for the closure, and the Connecticut Post also reported that gift cards were to be redeemed before the final day of service.
What closed, where, and when
Water Street Cafe’s final day was Saturday, November 7, according to the Connecticut Post and Patch. Both outlets identified the restaurant as being in Stonington Borough, with its longtime home at 143 Water St. The closure affects a specific coastal dining destination in southeastern Connecticut, not a broader group of locations.
The restaurant’s history stretched back to April 14, 1994, when Hayes-Houlihan and Houlihan opened the business after careers in New York City hospitality and catering, according to the source material provided and the Connecticut Post. The published accounts describe a small opening footprint, then a series of moves as the business evolved.
Reports said the cafe moved into the Harbor View Restaurant in 1997. A fire destroyed that location about three and a half months later, according to the source material and the Connecticut Post. The business later returned to its original home before moving in 2002 to 143 Water St., the address most customers came to know.
The food that defined the restaurant
Coverage of the closing consistently tied Water Street Cafe’s identity to seafood and seasonal cooking. The source material described a menu rooted in local seafood and produce from southeastern Connecticut, with dishes drawing on French, Asian, and American traditions.
Among the dishes named in the source material were Stonington oysters, New England clam chowder, lobster spring rolls, escargot pot pie, duck with scallops, seafood macaronade, seasonal fish, and a changing oyster list. That mix helps explain why the closure matters to diners who followed the local seafood scene and to home cooks interested in how regional restaurants build menus around what is available.
The Connecticut Post reported that Walter Houlihan was a Culinary Institute of America graduate and a former chef at the Ambassador Grill at the United Nations Plaza Hotel. The paper said the restaurant became known for French and Asian inspired signature dishes, while the source material emphasized that local ingredients kept the menu tied to the Connecticut coast.
What the restaurant meant to Stonington
The source material described Water Street Cafe as more than a dining room, pointing to whimsical decor, a handcrafted mahogany bar, and a style of service that encouraged repeat visits. That atmosphere, along with the food, helped the restaurant build a loyal following over three decades.
Accounts of the cafe’s recovery after the 1997 fire also point to its local standing. The source material said community support helped the restaurant reopen and continue serving Stonington diners. By the time it settled at 143 Water St. in 2002, it had already become part of the borough’s restaurant identity.
For readers, the practical takeaway is simple. Water Street Cafe has already closed, and the confirmed location affected is the Stonington Borough restaurant at 143 Water St. The published reports do not cite a specific closure reason, but they do document the end date, the owners’ farewell, and the menu style that made the restaurant a fixture for many Connecticut diners.
